
Mr. B was already a full-grown 5 year-old dog when we adopted him. We were very adamant about getting an adult dog, and we didn't even look at puppies. When I was discussing this with a friend the other day, she told me she was very adamant about getting a puppy and wouldn't even consider looking at a full-grown dog. This was probably the first time it occurred to me that we were very closed-minded about adopting puppies, and some people might not know all the benefits of adopting adult dogs.
There are benefits to both puppies and adult dogs, it just depends on your lifestyle and what you're looking for.
Here are some benefits we found when we adopted our adult dogs:
1) You already know what you're getting. It was really important for me to have a dog with a good personality, and I thought it would be hard to tell the differences among puppies. See, when I was growing up I was in charge of picking the family dog. We went to look at the "Free Puppies" and I remember the reason I chose my dog, Benji (yes, this was the '80's), was because he came up and licked my hand. He was a good puppy, but even despite all the 4-H training we did with him, he grew up to be a crazy and neurotic dog. I didn't want to make that mistake again,and I knew I couldn't handle that kind of energy in the city, so I definitely wanted to know the dog's personality before I adopted them. Imagine that you want an energetic, fun dog and you end up with this one:

Even with all the training available, you won't be able to change a dog's personality. I actually chose Miss M, who was a 2-year old dog at the time, because she was engaging, loved people, and loved dog-training. When choosing our second dog, we wanted to make sure he was submissive enough to put up with Miss M's bullying. We didn't want to deal with any adolescent Alpha issues. Luckily, Mr. B turned out to be the perfect submissive dog:

2) I didn't want to deal with potty-training issues. Being adults, our pooches came already potty-trained. This was huge for me because I didn't want to be out on the dark streets of Chicago in the middle of the night, where the rats roam the sidewalks and suspicious people are in the alleys, with only a tiny puppy to protect me.
3) Adult dogs are often overlooked. We knew there were so many adult dogs looking for homes that are often overlooked because they're not as little and cute anymore. We knew there would be many amazing adult dogs who often have to wait longer to be adopted. Miss M's rescue group,
New Leash on Life, has been successful adopting out many amazing "Senior Dogs" ranging from 9+ years. Plus, most of the time if an adult has made it through the rigors and numbers of a shelter system, you know they're going to be a good dog.
At the same time, I definitely understand the benefits of adopting puppies. Besides being cute, there are a couple of reasons I wish we had our dogs since they were puppies.
1) Care issues. When we met
this dog, he was already 2 years old and had the whitest teeth ever. His owner had been brushing his teeth since he was a puppy, so he was already used to it. Miss M. had a problem where her nails had never been trimmed properly as a puppy, so she had these huge monster nails that were really sharp and hard to cut.
2) We will never know how cute they were as puppies. We always wonder what our pooches looked like as puppies. We found this picture and we imagine this is what Mr. B looked like when he was younger:

And Miss M. would look a little like this, except more smooshy and brindle:

3) We would have them longer. Though
our neighbor with Puppy B did have 2 pitbulls that lived to be 16 and 17 years-old, so we're hopeful.
How have your experiences been? What other pros and cons do you find having puppies or adopting adult dogs?